Building a house in GD-II

how to estimate home building costs

Is 2009 a good time to build a house?

As I write this (Jan. '09) a new president is about to step into the most perfect economic storm since the great depression. While hope is high (too high?) that Obama will be able to make bold things happen, the worldwide financial meltdown is starting to spread to the everyday economy of jobs and purchasing power.

Can the new president surf his way through this storm and stay on top of the wave or, are we already in Great Depression 2? 

Historical side notes:
  • World War One was called the "Great War" until we entered WW-II in 1941. 
  • Many economists say that it was only WW-II that got us out of GD-I. A chilling thought.

One of the most understandable discussions of what is going on now, how deep the problems lie, and how they might be repaired is in "The End of the Financial World as We Know It", by Michael Lewis and David Einhorn. (An Op-ed essay in the NY Times.)

The chart below shows the build-up of market forces before and after GD-I compared to where we were in Nov. '08.

Dow chart - great depression vs 2008

"History doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme." Mark Twain

On the other hand (a standard phrase of the economic community) we could just be seeing the markets getting back to their longer term trend lines. We might overshoot a bit here but can expect to bounce back to the yellow line (hope, hope).

dow depression best case chart

While the stock market is not the economy, the Dow Jones does do a pretty good job of predicting the faith of investors in the long-term health of the business environment. That is why a stock market rise is often the first sign of a looming recovery.

At any rate...

Here are some pretty safe economic bets for 2009:

  • Unemployment will rise as businesses adjust to lower demand for their products and services.
  • Borrowing money is likely to continue to be difficult.
  • Prices will continue to fall for many of the things we buy (especially true in housing where prices for materials and labor are both falling).
Longer-term (it could be several years) prices are almost certainly going to rise fast once again. This is because of the huge amount of new money being manufactured now by the Treasury and FED in an attempt to fight off a depressionary spiral of falling employment, demand and prices.

When you make excessive New Money you dilute the purchasing power of Existing Money - this is the definition of inflation and economists, government and businesses like inflation better than deflation since it is something they have more control over.

If you build in 2009:

While we are going through "a rough patch" as George Bush the younger used to say, an optimist can easily see a number of advantages to building in such an economic environment:
  • Materials prices are as much as 50% less than they were in 2006. Ask for and expect big discounts. Retailers are eager to keep their inventory moving.
  • Construction help, subcontractors and even friends and family are likely to have more time to help and/or a willingness to work for less.
  • If you are able to work with out-of-pocket cash you will find your dollars go even further.
  • If you are laid off yourself, you may find you make more working on your house than you did at your old job.
If you build a smaller, energy and space efficient expandable house - one that uses common materials and simple construction techniques - then you are perfectly poised to expand the home or sell it at a profit later when things pick up in the future.

While it is true that home prices may continue to fall a bit more, you are more likely to be building near the bottom of the market cycle than at the top. Pity the poor fool who got a 95% loan to build that 4,000 sf mini-mansion in 2006!

And, should things get even nastier than we now expect, where would you rather be?
  • In a city apartment or a suburban house
  • In a more self-sufficient country home with a garden and woodlot

Get Involved with Building your own Shelter.

There is much to learn about the design and building of a house (see our Best Books list). See our article on 5 Ways to Build a House. You can be an involved owner-builder AND get help from others! Don't do what doesn't feel right or isn't fun. Houses are much happier places to live in if the people building it had FUN (and were therefore flexible, inventive and perhaps even unconventional - gasp!)

Getting a stock plan that comes close to meeting your basic space needs and then modifying and building that plan with local help is a less expensive alternative to spending 10% of your total budget on an architect and 20% of the construction budget on contractor overhead and profit. This is even before paying yourself for your own work. (See our Building Costs article.)

Working up an exciting design that meets your space and budget needs is one of the first and most important owner-builder projects you will do. It becomes the foundation of everything that follows. But, don't get too tight about planning every detail. Opportunities will show up that were not put down on paper and could not have been anticipated. You need to jump on these and let the house evolve its own character and direction. Many of these unanticipated changes will be things people will love about this house long after you are gone. 

We make our plans easy to customize because we think you will build a better house by staying awake to opportunities and getting involved. Here's to FUN and SUCCESS on your project! And don't forget the Forum. We are here to help and we love to hear about your project. Check out the Gallery if you haven't already.

how to estimate home building costs

Building a new home in tough economic times